I wasn’t a graphic novel fan, until I got Through The Woods by Emily Carroll. It was beautiful and the story really followed a horror fairytale format. The story was lush and the illustrations were beautiful. When the announcement came through, Carroll would be releasing another book this year. I waited very patiently for my library to purchase it. I was so happy that it came just in time for the #LOHFReadathon. I am using When I Arrived at the Castle as my LGBTQIA+ choice.
Synopsis: A cat girl arrives at a castle all set to kill the “woman” that lives there.
What I liked: As always the illustrations where STUNNING. Absolutely beautiful!! I really enjoy the color palette that Carrol uses. I enjoyed the premise of the story and the gothic leanings that were present. I appreciated the nod to Dracula. But what I really get here is Elizabeth Báthory. There is a part in the story where the woman is talking to the girl and is discussing how many have come before her etc….which is really what firmly lodged that idea in my head. There was a tiny bit of Dracula thrown in there for good measure but the other comes through more prominently .
What I didn’t like: I feel like there is a bit of story that is missing. The beginning and the ending are fully formed but I feel like there is something missing in the middle. I wanted to know more.
Star Rating: 3 stars
My thoughts: So I feel pretty let down here as I really loved Through The Woods. The illustrations weren’t the issue it was more the story. The story just felt lacking. I wanted to love it. I really really wanted to. Alas, I didn’t. Illustrations alone can’t carry a story. There needs to be some meat to the story.